Case Study 14-7 Conflict-Handling Styles

Case Study 14-7 Conflict-Handling Styles

For each of the five scenarios described below, determine what is the most appropriate conflict handling

style(s).

Scenario One

A radiologist on the staff of a large community hospital was stopped after a staff meeting by a

colleague in internal medicine. On Monday of the previous week, the internist referred an elderly

man with chronic, productive cough for chest X-ray, with a clinical diagnosis of bronchitis. Thursday

morning the internist received the radiologist's written X-ray report with a diagnosis of "probable

bronchogenic carcinoma." The internist expressed his dismay that the radiologist had not

called him much earlier with a verbal report. Visibly upset, the internist raised his voice, but did

not use abusive language.

How should the radiologist handle this conflict with the internist?

Scenario Two

The Family and Community Medicine Division of a large-staff model HMO serves a population

that is ethnically diverse. The senior management team of the HMO, spurred by repeated complaints

from representatives of one racial group, has encouraged the division, all of whose physicians

are white, to diversify. Several black and Hispanic physicians with strong credentials apply

for the open positions, but none is hired. Weeks later, a young female family physician learns from

several colleagues that the division director has identified her as racist and the obstructionist to

recruiting. The comments attributed to her are not only false but are also typical of discriminatory

statements that she has heard the division chief utter. The rumors about her "behavior" have

circulated widely in the division.

How should the young female family physician handle this conflict with the division chief?

Scenario Three

A manager who reports to the Vice President for Clinical Affairs (VPCA) of a tertiary-care hospital

hired a young woman to supervise development of a large community outreach program.

During the first four months of her employment, several behavioral problems came to the VPCA's

attention: (1) complaints from community physicians that the coordinator criticizes other physicians

in public; (2) concerns from two community leaders that the coordinator is not truthful; and

(3) written reports about the project that label and blame others, sometimes in language that is

disrespectful. The VPCA spoke several times to the manager about these problems. The manager

reported other dissatisfactions with the coordinator's performance, but he showed no sign of dealing

with the behavior. Two more complaints come in, one from an influential community leader.

How should the VPCA handle this conflict with the manager?

Scenario Four

The medical school in an academic health center recently implemented a problem-based curriculum,

dramatically reducing the number of lectures given and substituting small-group learning

that focuses on actual patient cases. Both clinical and basic science faculty are feeling 

stretched in their new roles. In the past, dental students took the basic course in microanatomy
with medical students. The core lectures are still given but at different times that do not match
with the dental-curriculum schedule. The anatomists insist that they don't have time to teach
another course specifically for dental students. The dean has informed the chair of the Department
of Anatomy and Cell Biology that some educational revenues will be redirected to the dental
school if the faculty do not meet this need.

How should the dean handle this conflict with the chair of the Department of Anatomy and Cell
Biology?

Scenario Five
The partners in a medical group practice are informed by the clinic manager that one physician
member of the group has been repeatedly upcoding procedures for a specific diagnosis. This issue
first came to light six months ago. At that time the partners met with him, clarified the Medicare
guidelines, and outlined the threat to the practice for noncompliance. He argued with their view,
but ultimately agreed to code appropriately. There were no infractions for several months, but
now he has submitted several erroneous codes. One member of the office staff has asked whether
Medicare would consider this behavior "fraudulent."